Catering Loyalty Programs: Why Burger-Style Loyalty Breaks at $1,200 Orders

Picture this: You just received a $1,200 catering order at your restaurant. It’s the kind of sale that makes your week. Now ask yourself: Does your standard loyalty program designed for someone buying a $10 burger make sense here? If you’re running a burger-style loyalty scheme such as buy 10 get 1 free or small point perks, it’s likely about to crack under the weight of that giant order.

Why? Because catering loyalty is a different beast. The stakes and order sizes are higher, and the old tricks that work for frequent diners can fall flat for catering clients. In this article, we’ll explore how traditional loyalty programs fail in the catering context and how to reinvent your approach.

‍
Why Do Traditional Loyalty Programs Fail for Catering Orders?
‍

Traditional restaurant loyalty programs were built to drive frequent small purchases such as coffee punch cards or apps that reward your tenth burger with a free one. They thrive on routine visits and emotional brand loyalty. But catering orders are infrequent, high-value transactions often made by pragmatic professionals. Applying a standard buy X get one free deal to catering can be disastrous.

For example, giving a free item after 10 orders might mean comping a hundreds-of-dollars order, a hit no restaurant wants to take. In short, the typical loyalty model doesn’t translate because the scale and motivations in catering are completely different.

In a traditional loyalty program, the goal is to encourage the customer who spends $10 or $20 at a time to come back frequently. The rewards such as a free side or a discount after several visits are sized for those smaller transactions. This burger-style loyalty assumes the customer is an individual craving your food and delights in a small perk like a free drink as a personal treat. It works great when you’re trying to build habit and routine, for example a daily coffee buyer.

Catering, however, runs on a different frequency and scale. A catering client might order only once a month, but that single order could equal 50 individual burgers in value. The person placing the order is often spending someone else’s money such as a corporate budget and is focused on reliability and volume, not a free dessert.

If your loyalty program offers a free entrée after 100 points, a catering customer who just spent $1,200 might shrug at a reward worth $10. That’s less than one percent of their purchase. Small loyalty perks break at scale. They either seem trivial in the context of a huge order, or if you try to scale them up, for example 10 percent back on $1,200, you give away too much.

To sum up, burger-style loyalty programs are built for frequency, not huge order size. They fail catering customers by offering the wrong incentives and can even wreck your margins if you’re not careful. Recognizing this failure is the first step to fixing it. Next, we’ll examine how loyalty for frequency differs from loyalty for big spenders.

‍

What’s the Difference Between Loyalty for Frequent Visits and Loyalty for Large Orders?
‍

Loyalty programs geared toward frequent visits reward customers for coming often. They’re about frequency. Think of the regular who stops by three times a week. The loyalty program nudges them to make that fourth visit with a small reward. In contrast, loyalty for large orders such as catering is about rewarding high spending and volume, making someone feel valued for dropping a big chunk of money at once, even if they do it rarely.

In practical terms, this means a shift from counting visits to counting dollars. A catering loyalty program might track total spend or order size, offering perks when a client hits $500, $1,000, or $5,000 in purchases rather than every tenth visit. It’s a move from a punch-card mentality to a spend and get mentality, tailored to infrequent but hefty transactions.

Let’s break that down. In a frequency-based program, the mindset is how do I get this customer to visit one more time this week. The rewards are often things like free coffee after five visits or a bonus item on your next purchase. The economics assume lots of small transactions. You can give a little freebie now and then to keep them coming back. Emotional drivers are key here. Customers participate because they love the brand and enjoy the game of earning rewards, think Starbucks fans chasing stars.

With large-order loyalty, the mindset shifts to how do I get this client to choose us for their next big order. Here, trust and value drive loyalty more than habit. The office manager ordering $1,000 of catering isn’t coming weekly out of sheer love for your sandwiches. They come back if you consistently deliver and make their job easier.

There’s also a different success metric. In traditional loyalty, success might be measured by increased visit frequency or incremental add-on sales per visit. In catering loyalty, success could be measured by repeat order rate and average order value growth. In essence, frequency loyalty is about habit and uses small, frequent rewards. Order-size loyalty is about value and uses scaled rewards or tiered benefits. Both aim to build loyalty, but they play by different rules.
‍

Who Is the Real Loyal Catering Customer?
‍

The loyal catering customer is usually not a single hungry patron, but a professional buyer acting on behalf of a group or company. Think administrative assistants, office managers, sales reps, and pharmaceutical reps, people whose job often includes ordering food for others.

This customer isn’t driven by personal cravings or emotional attachment to your brand the way a regular diner might be. Instead, they’re practical, deadline-driven, and value reliability above all. In other words, they’re loyal to whoever makes their job easier and makes them look good in front of their team or clients. Winning their loyalty means understanding their unique needs: on-time delivery, consistent quality, easy ordering, and a reward.

It’s critical to recognize that this person often doesn’t eat the catering they order. Imagine an executive assistant arranging lunch for a 20-person meeting. She might be grabbing a salad from home while ordering $500 of your BBQ for the team. Her satisfaction with your service isn’t about how tasty the ribs were.

It’s about whether her boss and coworkers were happy, whether it arrived on time, and whether she got credit for organizing a successful lunch. Her decision to use you again hinges on professional trust, not personal appetite.

So what makes her or him a loyal customer? Consistency and appreciation. Consistency means every order is executed flawlessly. No surprises is the mantra. Appreciation means you acknowledge their role and value their business in a way that resonates with them. Remember, these buyers are not emotionally attached to your brand like a foodie might be. Their relationship with you is largely transactional. You help them accomplish a task. But you can foster loyalty by layering in personal recognition such as thank-you notes, check-in calls, and a loyalty program that rewards them in a meaningful way.

For example, some catering programs offer a reward for the order placer. Since the person placing the order often isn’t dining, a smart program might give that individual a little something for themselves. This acknowledges that their effort should be rewarded, not just the company’s purchase. Even a small gesture can turn an indifferent corporate buyer into a loyal advocate who feels this restaurant gets me.

In summary, your real catering customer is the decision-maker behind the order. They’re professionals first and diners second. They value efficiency, reliability, and a solution that makes them look good and feel appreciated. Keep that persona in mind as we move to the next pitfall: loyalty rewards that only offer more food and why that’s often a dead end in the catering game.
‍

Why Are Food-Only Loyalty Rewards a Dead End for Catering?
‍

If your catering loyalty rewards consist solely of more food from your restaurant, you’re likely missing the mark. Food-only rewards fail in catering because the person who earns the reward, the corporate buyer, may not benefit from it personally. Redeeming points for a free office platter or trays of appetizers might sound generous, but to a professional catering customer, it’s basically just asking them to do more of their job, order more food for the group, with little personal upside.

In contrast, rewards that feel personal or cash-like such as gift cards are far more motivating. This is why many successful catering loyalty programs let customers convert points into things like Amazon or Visa gift cards, or apply them as discounts on future orders. Those rewards feel real to the person ordering, almost like a bonus or thank-you for their effort rather than just more company sandwiches.

Think about it this way. An office manager named Sally coordinates $5,000 in catering every month. Over time, she’s accrued enough loyalty points for, say, $200 worth of free catering. Nice, right? But using that reward means she’ll give her company a $200 free lunch. It doesn’t do much for Sally directly. She might appreciate the savings for her department, but it’s not a personal incentive.

Now imagine instead that those points could get her a $200 Amazon gift card or $200 off her holiday party catering at home. Suddenly, the reward has a personal benefit. It feels like a bonus for her hard work. Which scenario will encourage Sally to keep ordering from you versus the competition?

Restaurant operators sometimes worry that offering gift cards or personal rewards verges on an unethical kick-back. It’s true you must be thoughtful. Transparency and company policies matter. But when done right, it’s a win-win.

One more reason food-only rewards fall flat is novelty and variety. The same person ordering catering might handle dozens of lunches. A free repeat of the same food isn’t exciting. But a reward that stands out can break the monotony and create a positive emotional response.

Bottom line: Don’t trap your catering loyalty in a free food box. Points only good for more sandwiches won’t build the loyalty you want. Instead, offer rewards with real-world value to the person placing the orders. That might be a gift card, something that says thanks for your business, we appreciate you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I create a separate loyalty program just for catering customers?

Yes. Catering loyalty solves a different problem than dine-in loyalty. It needs to reward large order value, reliability, and repeat business from professional buyers, not frequent small visits. Trying to force catering into a dine-in loyalty system usually weakens both.

What rewards motivate catering customers the most?

Rewards that feel personal and cash-like work best. Amazon gift cards, account credits, and flexible perks consistently outperform food-only rewards because they benefit the individual placing the order, not just the company paying for it.

Why do food-only rewards fail in catering?

Because the person placing the order often does not eat the food. Free trays or platters feel irrelevant to them and do not change behavior. Loyalty breaks when the reward does not align with who is actually making the decision.

Is it ethical to reward the individual placing the catering order?

Yes, when done transparently and within reasonable limits. Most companies allow modest appreciation rewards. When positioned as a loyalty benefit and not a hidden incentive, these rewards are widely accepted and effective.

How should catering loyalty success be measured?

Not by visit frequency. Success should be measured through repeat catering orders, growth in average order value, and migration from marketplace orders to direct ordering, all of which signal real loyalty and healthier margins.